(Vous parlez français? Cliquez ici!)
The Graphic Liner Vinyl Pen Eyeliner has a glossy finish and is more translucent than the Ink Liner, but you can easily apply a thick layer to obtain a rich and dark black.
The Ink Liner Matte Liquid Eyeliner is a highly pigmented, very dark and opaque black with a matte finish. I don't think I have ever seen a matte eyeliner like this one!
Make Up For Ever's Ink Liner and Graphic Liner
Both eyeliners have great staying power : they don't smudge or flake off! I was surprised to find out that they aren't waterproof though, but to be fair they aren't supposed to be.
The Ink Liner dries quickly which is always a good thing for an eyeliner! The Graphic Liner doesn't dry as quickly so I didn't like it as much, but I have to admit that I already have a soft spot for the Ink Liner's matte finish anyway.
They are quite easy to use (well, eyeliner isn't easy to apply but you get the idea), the felt tip applicator isn't too stiff, yet not too supple either.
I'm in love with the Ink Liner, it's so black and matte!
The Make Up For Ever Ink Liner retail for $27 CAD for 3.5ml and the Graphic Liner retail for $29 CAD for 1ml.
(I received these products in order to evaluate them and give my opinion, but rest assured that my comments are always honest and impartial.)